Stop complaining about the ALS Ice Bucket Challenge

Stop complaining about the ALS Ice Bucket Challenge


More than 200 people took part in the Ice Bucket Challenge at King George V Memorial Park in West Kowloon.
More than 200 people took part in the Ice Bucket Challenge at King George V Memorial Park in West Kowloon.
Photo: Felix Wong/SCMP

The ALS Ice Bucket Challenge is as controversial as it is viral. For every single fad that has been sweeping across the internet as of late, there has always been an accompanying troupe of criticism. Name-calling comes into play. “Slacktivism.” “Hashtag-activism.” “Narcissists.” In my opinion, ignore the whiners. The ALS Ice Bucket Challenge is not the first, nor the last, of internet trends, and its benefits trump the petty issues that critics seem to hold on to.

The ALS challenge has, as of writing, raised USD$80 million. 80 million. That’s around 40 times more than it received compared to the same period of time last year. The once obscure disease is finally in the spotlight of the public eye and media attention. This is any charity’s dream, especially for smaller ones like the ALS Association. More people than ever before know about the disease, whose victims include Lou Gehrig, the famous baseball player, and Stephen Hawking, the world-famous theoretical physicist, and many have even suggested new research methods and ways to best use the massive influx in donations.

All in all, I think critics of the social movement are suffering from an overdose of idealism. Call me realistic or even cynical, but I believe that to have a disease raise so much public awareness and funding in such a limited timeframe is nothing short of a technological miracle, only made possible through the power of social media. The problems that critics raise are only minor, necessary evils; a little piece of extra baggage that was inevitable in helping this campaign reach the level of success that it did.

Yet these opponents keep whining about how the money could’ve been better spent or where the resources could’ve been better used. “You’re wasting all this water when children in Africa are dying of thirst every day!” Are you now suddenly an activist for You probably waste more water in the shower or brushing your teeth every day. I don’t think a lot of critics are super water-conscious people themselves.

“It’s all about narcissism and promoting yourself instead of the disease.” Some people may misuse the challenge for publicity – a few more likes on Facebook or Instagram – but at least they’re spreading awareness. However, judging by the numbers, the contrary is quite clear. Egocentrics are in a small minority. The challenge works a bit like advertising. Advertisers don’t expect everyone to buy their product immediately after seeing the ad; but maybe one out of five or ten people will buy the product, or in this case, really do some research and donate to ALS. And when you spread it to millions of people online, that’s a lot of eyes devoted to the cause. Complain all you want about celebrities, say that they’re just doing this for publicity, but they’re taking advantage of their huge fan-bases to encourage more people to both do the challenge and to donate. Countless ALS victims are elated and grateful to know that their disease is garnering so much unprecedented attention.

“You could’ve just donated and not dumped an ice bucket on yourself!” Give us a break, will you? Ignoring the fact that I HIGHLY doubt that just donating yourself and nominating a few other friends to do so would make the movement so viral and spread the way that it did, greatly diminishing the effects of the movement, there’s also the oft-ignored fact that we’re humans after all. We’re social creatures. We want to have fun. We want to be part of a community; part of something that matters. Had we just donated in secret, we would’ve disconnected ourselves from the cause and the campaign. Of course, in the unrealistic, ideal minds of critics, the movement would’ve spread like wildfire just by humbly donating. And everyone would devote time to further research the disease. And the disease would be cured. And we’d all be living in some utopian society.

The internet has seen a lot of trends come and go over the past few years. An inherent characteristic of humans is to be easily influenced and swept away by the newest fad, or the coolest-thing-to-do-right-now. In terms of online trends, the ALS Ice Bucket Challenge is probably one of the better ones; just think about “planking”, the cinnamon challenge (eating a teaspoon of cinnamon and trying to swallow it), “neknomination” (gulping a glass of beer then nominating friends to do the same), or even the ridiculous knockout challenge (which is to actually make yourself pass out by getting someone to choke you). Now in contrast, the ALS Ice Bucket Challenge, with its charitable intentions, doesn’t seem so bad anymore, does it?

This article appeared in the Young Post print edition as
Stop the Ice Bucket moans


To post comments please
register or


Susan Olens


It a great joy to me today, as i can now stand and do any work all by myself. ALS virus almost killed my life. I was diagnosed with ALS some years back, but all pains and sickness came to an end last year when with the help of my daughter, i contacted Dr Bude who sent me some herbal medicine which cured my disease in just weeks. My cure is a miracle and i want all with ALS to also get their miracle now. Dr Bude s contact emails are and do get to him now for your cure.

Theresa Christensen


My ALS (amyotrophic lateral sclerosis) symptoms started out with a "foot drop" on my right foot. From there my right leg lost all muscle tone and after a while the entire right leg muscles were gone. Also my fingers and thumbs "contract" at times. Left arm was losing muscle tone too.The neurologist. started me on Riluzole , to reduce symptoms and slow down progression but I could not tolerate them for long due to severe side effects. I decided to adopt a more natural approach and started on ALS Disease Natural formula from THE HERBAL GARDENS, the ALS natural formula immensely helped my condition, it reversed my ALS. my slurred speech. And then the inability to eat without getting choked, strangled, and coughing. and others gradually disappeared. Visit THE HERBAL GARDENS via their official web-site ww w. Theherbalgardens. org. This ALS natural herbal formula has improved the quality of my life greatly, Since the procedure I enjoy walking the dog for my daily exercise. DON’T GIVE UP HOPE!!!