How classmates tormented abused child

How classmates tormented abused child

A student who attended the same school as one of the 13 siblings found chained to their beds in their filthy California home reveals how one was bullied at school


The ordinary-looking house where 13 siblings were kept in horrific conditions in Perris, California.
Photo: TNS

The oldest of the 13 California siblings who authorities said were imprisoned by their parents was frail, smelly and picked on as a grade school student, one of her classmates has said. 

In a heart-wrenching Facebook post, Taha Muntajibuddin told of how the now-29-year-old woman had been picked on at school. 

She was rescued with her starving brothers and sisters from their home in Perris, California, on January 14. Neighbours and relatives said they were unaware of the children’s treatment until authorities arrested the parents and revealed what they found inside.

Muntajibuddin attended kindergarten through third grade with her in Fort Worth, Texas. After learning of the case, he shared on Facebook his “overwhelming sense of guilt and shame” over how she was treated.

Schools first line of defence against abuse in Hong Kong, say NGOs after girl, 5, dies in Tuen Mun

Muntajibuddin, a pediatrics resident doctor in Houston, described her as “a frail girl, had pin-straight hair with bangs, and often wore the same purple outfit.”

He wrote that it was jarring to learn that the girl, who was teased in school for being smelly, “quite literally had to sit in her own waste because she was chained to her bed.”

“It is nothing but sobering to know that the person who sat across from you at the lunch table went home to squalour and filth while you went home to a warm meal and a bedtime story,” he wrote.

The post has got a strong reaction, with some condemning Muntajibuddin for his behaviour as a child. Others praised him for addressing it. Muntajibuddin said he was surprised by the reaction.

Hong Kong siblings tell of dead girl's abuse

“It was just meant to be an honest lesson: take it or leave it,” he said.

Crowley Independent School District spokesman Anthony Kirchner confirmed Muntajibuddin and the victim had attended the same school. Kirchner said he was unable to confirm when she enrolled or when she left school, or whether any of her younger siblings attended, because districts are only required to keep elementary student records for five years.

Another classmate, Stephanie Hernandez, said in a Facebook message that the girl was quiet and always wore dirt-stained jeans that were too small. Hernandez said she often was bullied.

“I remember someone kind of slung her around like a rag doll,” said Hernandez, a registered nurse in Mansfield, Texas.

David Turpin, 57, and Louise Turpin, 49, have been arrested.
Photo: Associated Press

Police arrested David Turpin, 57, and Louise Turpin, 49, after their 17-year-old daughter climbed out a window and called 911. Authorities found the siblings, ages 2 to 29, in the family’s filthy California home, three of whom were shackled to beds and all except the youngest child malnourished.

The couple has pleaded not guilty to torture and other charges.

The Riverside University Health System Foundation, which is collecting money for the siblings, so far has received 1,500 donations totaling US$120,000, spokeswoman Kim Trone. People from across the world also have been sending toys, blankets and clothing, she said.

About 20 people, including nurses and psychologists, have offered to take the seven adult siblings and six minors and keep them together, said Mary Parks, a spokeswoman for the Riverside County Department of Public Social Services. “People from around the country are offering to foster them and adopt them,” she said.

Neighbours bring toys and flowers to the home where the siblings were kept prisoner.
Photo: Associate Press

The siblings were all taken to hospitals, but Parks said she could not discuss their conditions. The agency typically seeks to place children with a relative and keep siblings together, she said.

Muntajibuddin said he is hopeful his former classmate can recover and live an enriched life. He said despite being bullied by her peers, she “was still one of the most pleasant people I have had the opportunity to meet. She had this whimsical optimism to her that couldn’t be dampened, couldn’t be doused no matter what anybody threw at her.”

He said he has learned from his experience and hopes others do, too. “The resounding lesson here is a simple one, something that we’re taught from the very beginning,” Muntajibuddin wrote. “Be nice.” 

Edited by Ginny Wong


To post comments please
register or