Talking points: The school rule I would change if I were the principal

Talking points: The school rule I would change if I were the principal

Hate it when you can't talk back? Well you can with Young Post. Learn and share with students around Hong Kong
Minal Daswani, 17, Island School

At my school, Year 13 students are allowed to leave early if they have a free period. This isn't exactly a rule, but it has become the norm.

Unfortunately, although we can leave early, we're not allowed to come in late if we have free periods in the morning.

If I were the principal, I would allow students who have free periods to come in later. This would help people like me who prefer to work late, sleep late and get up late, instead of going to bed early and getting up early.

Jessie Pang Yu-tung, 17, True Light Girls' College

If I were the school principal, I would allow students to eat in the street outside the school.

Students usually have lots of extra-curricular activities or tutorial lessons after school, so they may not have time to eat some food beforehand. They may even have their dinner very late.

Some food also needs to be eaten immediately, such as ice cream and milkshake.

Most importantly, eating on the street won't damage the school's image. Eating is a normal human need. Therefore, people won't have a good or bad impression about a school just because its students are seen eating on the street.

Henry Lui, 14, Sha Tin College

As the "supreme leader", I would strictly enforce the rule that bans students from playing online games at school.

The offenders take up a lot of bandwidth on the school network and might cause problems for other students who are actually being productive.

There is such a rule in our school, but it hasn't stopped some students from playing online games. We need to stop this kind of behaviour.

Sonali Gidwani, 17, West Island School

The school dress code states we are not allowed to wear denim shorts. This is unfair because a lot of the more modest shorts people have are made of this cotton fabric.

I can see why the school does this - to prevent people wearing ripped denim shorts that are too short.

However, they should ban only ripped denim shorts, instead of all types. It would make our lives a lot easier when choosing clothes to wear to school.

Sweetie Lui, 17, Yan Oi Tong Tin Ka Ping Secondary School

My schoolmates and I are not allowed to stay in classrooms or hang around corridors during the lunch break for security reasons.

All doors are closed at 1.15pm and opened again at 1.40pm. Afternoon lessons start at 2.05pm, so there's still time for people to steal things if they really want to. Here's my point. Why not leave the doors open and let the students protect things themselves?


Tell us which school rule you would change if you were the principal in the comment box below

In the next Talking Points, we'll be discussing what we wish we could tell our parents.


Other conversations:

- What do you think about e-learning?

- How can we eliminate the problem of caged homes and subdivided flats in Hong Kong?

- "If I were gay/lesbian, I would like to tell the world ..."

- Things I wish to know in life that I never learn about in school

- What I wish I could tell my parents

- How should schools start their Monday morning assembly?

- What's wrong with Liberal Studies?

- What worries you most about the upcoming school year?


To post comments please
register or


cho cho


If I were the principal, I would change this school rule definitely – greeting to the teachers every lesson. Why? That’s because greeting is only a mean to show how polite you are to the teachers but that doesn’t mean that we do it with our true heart. Using such an action is sometimes a pretense

* jason_hung


If I were the principal, I would change the rule which forbids students having their lunch in classroom. As I believe that it'd solve the problem of having no enough tables for all of us in the playgrounds. Also, theft can be prevented since we can always set our eye on it.

Liam Fung


If I were the principal, I would change the rule of wearing uniform, as many people do not enjoy wearing it and it feels quite "artificial" in a sense to be wearing something you don't want to.

* kris_leung


Kick the original discipline prefect team away and start a new team called – Secret student intelligence. Instead of having discipline prefects who normally scare away schoolmates around them, what could be more interesting than having student spies who patrol in the campus without others noticing

Wong Ho Yan


Wow, that’s a very good question that I’ve always been thinking about it. If I were the head mistress of my school, there would be a long list of rules that I was going to change because of their absurdity. But which one came first? It should be the most unreasonable one- girls have to wear dresse