Minority discrimination

Minority discrimination

UN committee's report says the city should stop putting students of certain ethnic backgrounds in 31 specific schools


Equal Opportunities Commissioner Dr York Chow Yat-ngok (right) plans to look into the city's education policy.
Equal Opportunities Commissioner Dr York Chow Yat-ngok (right) plans to look into the city's education policy.
Photo: Dickson Lee/SCMP
Putting Hong Kong's ethnic minority students in designated schools is a form of discrimination, a United Nations committee's report says. Of the city's 852 government-funded schools, 31 enrol mostly ethnic minorities and teach limited Chinese.

At a hearing last month, The Committee on the Rights of the Child - an independent arm of the UN - urged the Hong Kong government to end the policy.

The hearing was held so the UN committee could review whether Hong Kong was sticking to the Convention on the Rights of the Child.

Those schools were once labelled as "designated schools" by the government. The tag was removed this year.

Hong Kong Unison director Fermi Wong Wai-fun, who campaigns for the rights of ethnic minorities, said: "It is a very strong tone for the report to confirm the existence of de facto discrimination."

The government hit back, saying the parents choose to put their children in the 31 schools. But the UN committee said the mainstream schools lacked the support to look after those students.

A spokesman for a designated school said a few months ago that to have ethnic minority students blend with students in mainstream schools would take a long time, as schools would have to be ready for the change. The current method allows designated schools to focus resources on ethnic minority students.

Equal Opportunities Commissioner Dr York Chow Yat-ngok said last month he would launch an inquiry into the city's education policy.

You might also like:

- Harrison Chung has a vision - to fight for an education system which won't leave ethnic minority students out

- Op-Ed: No more elitism in education

- The Orochen people are having a hard time settling in villages after generations as hunters so with the help of Chao Hing and his charity Earthpulse, they are restoring their culture one piece at a time



To post comments please
register or


issac chan


I think there is a must to make some policies to help the ethnic minorities. It is because if we don't give out policy, the ethnic minorities cannot learn well. However, I think the the children that is not born in Hong Kong, should not use the facilities in hong kong. So, there will be more space f