Rumble box: Old vs New

Rumble box: Old vs New

In this week's Rumble Box, Joyee Chan and Leon Lee are engaged in an argument about Old vs New.


You may think that we should all buy used clothes and DVDs from charity shops so that useful items don't end up in landfills which are nearly full. But think again. Not all objects can be recycled. We must consider safety, cleanliness and quality.

Take second-hand cars, for example. You can check however much you want, but you'll never know how the previous driver used the vehicle. There are so many things to test - from the engine and brakes to the service history. There's always a chance you'll miss something - a crack in the exhaust pipe, or a rusty timing belt, for instance. You wouldn't want to find that out when you're driving at full speed along a highway.

For safety reasons, you shouldn't also buy second-hand children's furniture. You wouldn't know if a crib was recalled or if it was installed correctly. Safety standards change all the time, too. For your little baby, you really want the best.

Now think about textbooks. New ones will have enough space for your notes; old ones will be full of doodles or stains made by the previous owner. And imagine sleeping on someone else's mattress? You would be lying on their mould, bacteria, and bodily fluids. Yuck! Besides, even really good mattresses are only supposed to last eight to 10 years, and it's hard to know for sure how old a used one may be.

I love getting great deals from weekend markets, but there are some things you don't want to buy second-hand. They may end up costing you more, and could endanger your health.

Joyee Chan


You might ask: who wants old, used things when you can have something that's perfectly packaged and brand new? But while a glittering new toy may be very appealing, it lacks the character and sturdiness of a second-hand product.

Most second-hand goods are half the price of their original cost. They may not be the most trendy or up-to-date, but as long as they work, they are good enough for me. Let's face it, the words in a used copy of Harry Potter are exactly the same as those in a brand new one! Many charity shops may surprise you with the quality of their goods. And it's also great fun looking for things in such places. I always come out with something I didn't expect - it's like a treasure hunt! Anyone can go to H&M or Uniqlo and buy the same printed tee everybody else has, but in a charity shop, you can get some special, one-of-a-kind pieces.

Lastly, I'm sure I don't need to remind you about the three Rs: Reduce, Reuse, Recycle. Buying second-hand goods satisfies all three! By reusing items and giving them new life, you are making sure our landfills won't be clogged up with more and more rubbish.

As the old saying goes: "One man's trash is another man's treasure."

Leon Lee

We hope you enjoyed the rumble. If you have an idea for a fun topic, e-mail us at with "Rumble Box" in the subject line and we could be wrangling your topic idea next week


To post comments please
register or