Tianjin blast a reminder that China's self-censorship is crippling the country's progress

Tianjin blast a reminder that China's self-censorship is crippling the country's progress

china-blast_pe45.jpg

Smoke rise from the site of the explosions at the Binhai new district, Tianjin.
Photo: Reuters

They say “any publicity is good publicity”, but in China, it’s more like “any publicity is bad publicity”.

Last night, Tianjin, a city of 15 million people in northern China, heard an explosion and saw video footage of something that looked like an outtake from an end-of-the-world movie. Fireballs from the blast injured hundreds and killed dozens, and the death toll is still rising.

I first heard about it, not through any news alerts, but through Wechat Moments, as everyone asked: “What on earth happened in Tianjin?”

More than 12 hours later, there is still no answer to that.

Media outlets that are trying to get to the bottom of it are not having much luck either. A CNN correspondent in Tianjin was interrupted during a live TV report near a hospital close to the explosions and told to stop filming.

But it’s not just foreign media that are having a hard time finding out what happened. As is common during disasters on the mainland, social media remains under tight control when it comes to sharing information.

On Sina Weibo, some users have complained that their posts about the blasts have been deleted, and the number of searchable posts on the disaster has fluctuated, in a sign that authorities are manipulating or placing limits on the number of posts.

Chinese journalists were also blocked. One reporter who took photos inside a hospital was threatened by hospital security guards and forced to delete the images. A photo journalist from Beijing News was surrounded by seven policemen to ensure he deleted photos. “Delete them or we’ll cuff you,” they are reported as saying.

Beijing News is a best-selling newspaper in Tianjin’s neighbouring city. Which begs the question, what are the local media outlets doing at this point?

Tianjin TV, the official channel in Tianjin municipality, has made it clear that there has only been one kind of explosion: an explosion of drama. Sticking to its fixed schedule, Tianjin TV has been running cartoon shows and Korean dramas this morning in an attempt to pretend there is nothing wrong in the city.

This reminded me of something that happened in Qingdao, another city in northern China, two years ago.

There was an oil pipeline explosion in Qingdao in November 2013 and the only coverage by Qiangdao newspapers was to describe the central government’s responses to the incident and the bravery during rescue.

For several years, media organisations on the mainland would only report negative coverage if it affected a different province or city, so the government later banned this so-called “cross-regional reporting”.

It always seems like censorship is the government’s top priority, rather than seeking solutions or learning from past lessons.

Both the Qingdao explosion in 2013 and yesterday’s Tianjin explosion happened in industrial areas which are near residential areas. The close proximity of residential buildings to industrial areas is one of the reasons that both incidents resulted in such a high number of causalities.

“Are they that confident, or are human lives that worthless?” a friend of mine said about the fact that residential buildings are less than one kilometre from the blast site in Tianjin.

Chinese President Xi Jinping called for “all-out efforts” to rescue those injured and minimise casualties from the explosions.

But all-out efforts are not enough, we need to learn from the disasters, and media censorship is certainly not the way.

Comments

To post comments please
register or

33 Comments

john smith

19:51pm

Many countries are improving their http://****bestdissertation-service.com and technical education rate & in this concern the tuition fee Of the student is exempted or the scholarship is enhanced by an equivalent amount. Scholarships of Higher amount are awarded to students engaged in post graduate studies & research.

Fatima

22:01pm

**** is illegal, in the sense you aren't alwleod to sell it or buy it. Yes you can possess it but you are not alwleod to obtain it.That makes it illegal in my book.These points are taken from the Govt of NSw website, and makes it very clear just what illegal **** is.# X rated films are legally available for sale or hire from the ACT or the Northern Territory (p 2).# In the States, the law only permits X rated films to be possessed for personal use. X rated films are not, and never have been, legally available for sale or hire in NSW (p 3).# Prior to the introduction of the X classification in 1984, ****ually explicit films were available for sale in NSW. They were unclassified and subject to the State’s indecency laws (p 3).# The X classification is a restrictive category of films that is defined to be unsuitable for minors (p 3).# The X classification is also defined under the National Classification Code to exclude all violent content. Depictions involving coercion and non-consent have been banned in X since 1984, with later prohibitions being placed on ****ually assaultive language, fetishes and purposefully demeaning depictions (p 3).

Kaio

06:10am

I got sent this video (took me about an hour to load with the crappy <a href="http://gfbvwcwwdk.com">inetnret</a> I have haha.) and I wasn't sure what it was about because I had no idea about the <a href="http://gfbvwcwwdk.com">inetnret</a> censorship I was thinking, oh I don't watch the news so I probably missed it. I was surprised to know that the media HAVEN'T been attacking this topic.I'm 15, and I go to high school at our high school we have a nanny net program that has blocked a **** load of websites which makes it hard to even USE the <a href="http://gfbvwcwwdk.com">inetnret</a>.When we need to do a project on something (a political matter maybe) we go on the <a href="http://gfbvwcwwdk.com">inetnret</a> 99% of the time. But, if we go on there and the political matter is against the side of the current government will that be blocked?How can we be sure that this Pedophilia Catcher' basically won't turn into another government tool that chooses what we read and what we don't, taking away our free speech?

Rasooljan

10:33am

**** is legal in some parts of Australia Lori. But depending on its clasiificatson, it is also illegal to sell in most states and even illegal to possess in certain areas of the NT and WA. I'm not talking about **** where other laws were broken either, I'm referring to the **** that gets banned because it has candle wax or BDSM. A common and legal practice performed in many Aussie bedrooms. Should Australians be banned from seeing acts they can perform legally?The Government's plan is not about tracking pedophiles. In fact, pedophiles will likely encrypt their connections because of this filter and make it harder for them to be tracked. The Government can already track those visiting illegal websites and do exactly that. This will not make it easier for them. You're happy to have the Government monitor what websites you visit? You think that is how a free society should operate?Migration is a sensible' alternative? http://mhpwtzuzti.com [url=http://naodifyfl.com]naodifyfl[/url] [link=http://jkmule.com]jkmule[/link]

Lynn

01:54am

Victory

03:30am

Turk

05:42am

Janais

07:36am

Chelsia

07:49am

Reignbeau

08:36am

Ethica

10:22am

Caiden

10:47am

Kellsie

10:59am

Roxanna

12:33pm

Ladainian

13:10pm

Ladainian

13:10pm

Brandywine

13:17pm

Veruca

14:09pm

astrologer a

14:38pm

Many people like your blogs. continuous it......

http://****astrologersanjaysharma.com/vashikaran-specialist/vashikaran-specialist-in-india.html
http://****astrologersanjaysharma.com/vashikaran-specialist/vashikaran-specialist-in-jaipur.html
http://****astrologersanjaysharma.com/vashikaran-specialist/vashikaran-specialist-in-ahmedabad.html
http://****astrologersanjaysharma.com/vashikaran-specialist/vashikaran-specialist-in-amritsar.html
http://****astrologersanjaysharma.com/vashikaran-specialist/vashikaran-specialist-in-chandigarh.html
http://****astrologersanjaysharma.com/vashikaran-specialist/vashikaran-specialist-in-mumbai.html
http://****astrologersanjaysharma.com/vashikaran-specialist/vashikaran-specialist-in-nasik.html
http://****astrologersanjaysharma.com/vashikaran-specialist/vashikaran-specialist-in-noida.html
http://****astrologersanjaysharma.com/vashikaran-specialist/vashikaran-specialist-in-bhopal.html

astrologer a

14:39pm

Great post !! Thanks for share that type blog. Many people like that blogs....

http://****mkshastriji.com/
http://****mkshastriji.com/black-magic-specialist-in-india.html
http://****mkshastriji.com/love-marriage-specialist.html
http://****mkshastriji.com/love-problem-solution.html
http://****mkshastriji.com/love-mantra.html
http://****mkshastriji.com/vashikaran-mantra-vidhi.html
http://****mkshastriji.com/intercast-marriage-problem.html
http://****mkshastriji.com/love-lost-back-by-vashikaran.html

astrologer a

14:40pm

Your post is much interesting and useful for us....

http://****vashikaranforallproblems.com/
http://****vashikaranforallproblems.com/about.html
http://****vashikaranforallproblems.com/vashikaran-specialist.html
http://****vashikaranforallproblems.com/love-marriage-specialist.html
http://****vashikaranforallproblems.com/black-magic-specialist.html
http://****vashikaranforallproblems.com/love-astrology.html
http://****vashikaranforallproblems.com/vashikaran-specialist.html
http://****vashikaranforallproblems.com/vashikaran-mantra.html
http://****vashikaranforallproblems.com/vashikaran-for-husband.html
http://****vashikaranforallproblems.com/love-back-solution.html

Pages