India's justice is slow to arrive [Review]

Published: 
By Melanie Leung
Listen to this article

Court showcases the flawed political system of India

By Melanie Leung |
Published: 
Comment

Latest Articles

SOTY 2022/23: Art runs in the family for Visual Artist second runner-up

SOTY 2022/23: Linguist (English) first runner-up loves to play devil’s advocate

Hong Kong children are taller and heavier over the last 30 years

Heavy rain in Hong Kong: Observatory issues 4th rainstorm warning in a week

Europe’s longest tunnel for testing hyperloop technology opens in the Netherlands

How customers, eateries are reacting to Hong Kong single-use plastics ban

However insecure Hongkongers feel about our city's political future, there's still some solace in knowing that our judicial system is fair and independent. Sadly, this isn't the case in India, as 28-year-old Chaitanya Tamhane's debut feature Court bluntly shows.

Fixing the camera at a wide angle, Court documents a dull Mumbai trial with long, unblinking shots. An argument is barely made before the indifferent judge dictates a summary to a court reporter and schedules the next hearing a month later. Like the trial, the scenes are slow and the seconds tick by before anything happens - like the characters involved, you almost forget that a man's freedom is at stake.

Narayan Kamble (Vira Sathidar) is a 65-year-old folk singer who criticises the government in his songs. He is arrested in connection with a man's death, then denied bail for a year despite his poor health and a lack of solid proof. Sathidar, an activist in real life with experience with the flawed judicial system, gives a convincing performance. He's charismatic while singing and quietly defiant as he testifies.

The court scenes are broken up with scenes of the lawyers going about their daily lives. This adds a layer of humanity, while highlighting how common cases such as Kamble's are in Indian life. Let's hope that will change soon.

Sign up for the YP Teachers Newsletter
Get updates for teachers sent directly to your inbox
By registering, you agree to our T&C and Privacy Policy
Comment