[Review] Not enough time for history 101

Published: 
By Chris Lau
Listen to this article
By Chris Lau |
Published: 
Comment

Latest Articles

SOTY 2022/23: Linguist (English) first runner-up loves to play devil’s advocate

Hong Kong children are taller and heavier over the last 30 years

Heavy rain in Hong Kong: Observatory issues 4th rainstorm warning in a week

Europe’s longest tunnel for testing hyperloop technology opens in the Netherlands

How customers, eateries are reacting to Hong Kong single-use plastics ban

In The Butler, director Lee Daniels chronicles the pain and hardship endured by fellow black Americans through the country's recent history.

It tells the story of butler Cecil Gaines (Forest Whitaker), from farm boy to a man with access to the world's most important men.

As a child in the segregated South of the 1920s, Cecil was a victim of white tyranny, seeing his father gunned down by his employer, and being forced to work as a servant.

Flash forward to the 1950s. Having worked in hotels, Cecil is a respected worker, and fate brings him to an interview for a job at the White House. The number one rule is not to be political.

Cecil is happy not to have an opinion in order to survive, even when race relations are being discussed. But trouble brews when his older son becomes a vocal advocate of black rights.

Whitaker gives a believable portrayal of a repressed servant, lost husband and confused father, and Oprah Winfrey is a surprising triumph of casting. But Daniels is overly ambitious, trying to fit too much into 132 minutes. The film offers an informative glimpse into black history, but lacks focus.

 

 

Sign up for the YP Teachers Newsletter
Get updates for teachers sent directly to your inbox
By registering, you agree to our T&C and Privacy Policy
Comment